The Arizona House of Representatives narrowly rejected a move aimed at disbanding the police department in a polygamist town. A bill before the House would have created a process to replace local police agencies with the county sheriff’s department if at least half of its officers lost their law enforcement certifications during an eight-year span.

The proposal was aimed at cops in the northern Arizona town of Colorado City. State Attorney General Tom Horne, a supporter of the bill, said Colorado City police officers who follow jailed polygamist leader Warren Jeffs are disregarding the law. But some argued the proposal unfairly targeted a single community.

The bill already passed the state Senate, but failed in the House on Wednesday in a 28-to-25 vote.