Late last month, Arizona Public Service announced it will propose a subscription model for data centers in an attempt to prevent energy costs from being shifted to residential customers.
Natural gas is set to supply most of that plan’s power.
APS currently estimates about 75% of that plan will come from natural gas, though the utility says clean energy will also be used.
That means potent greenhouse gas emissions will be produced to fulfill data center energy demands as utilities shift away from coal.
"It is a less of a greenhouse gas problem from the standpoint of compared to coal," said Martin Pasqualetti, an Arizona State University urban planning professor.
There are still other detractors.
"You're putting out less, but it's more powerful." Pasqualetti said.
While natural gas produces less carbon dioxide, it emits more methane, which traps 28 times more heat in the atmosphere than CO2.
“The objection to it is that you're kind of still moving in the same direction. You're still moving toward a fossil fuel future. And to the extent that there are alternatives to this, then you might want to consider doing that," he said.
Last month, APS also announced a 2,000 MW natural gas plant that will be built near Gila Bend. It will support all users, but it is expecting a large portion will be used for data centers.
"When you make a decision to build any kind of power plant, you're making the decision to operate for several decades. So, that locks you in for like two generations to a fossil-based fuel," he said.
Pasqualetti said there are other moves data centers could take to be more reliant on renewable energy, like shifting peak demand to when solar production is at its highest.
-
Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs wants ongoing funding for energy assistance programs, but she needs support from Republican lawmakers to make it happen.
-
Arizona added nearly 2-gigwatts of solar power, bringing the total amount statewide to about 11.5 gigawatts. To put that in perspective, APS’ peak demand last year was more than 8 and a half gigawatts.
-
The Trump administration has called on big tech companies to keep energy costs down amid the data center boom. But critics say the Trump administration's request does little to hold big tech companies accountable.
-
During a tour of an Xcel natural gas plant, the secretary criticized the state’s climate plan and said that keeping coal plants open was saving lives.
-
Arizona regulators have repealed renewable energy requirements for the state’s utilities, erasing rules first passed two decades ago.