An Arizona Appeals Court rejected an attempt by the state Republican Party and conservative groups to restrict the ways county election officials can verify signatures on early ballots.
The Arizona Republican Party, Arizona Free Enterprise Club, Restoring Integrity and Trust in Elections, and a Yavapai County voter filed a lawsuit in 2023 challenging state election rules, including the ways county recorders can verify a voter’s signature on their early ballot.
The plaintiffs specifically challenged rules allowing election workers to compare the signature on an early ballot to signatures on any other election-related document, including early ballot envelopes from prior elections.
They argued state law only allows recorders to use a person’s original voter registration for signature verification.
“Certain of these materials, and particularly early ballot envelopes submitted in prior elections, however, are not “registration records,” and hence are not a lawful comparative reference for conducting signature validation,” according to the original lawsuit.
A Yavapai County judge disagreed.
In a 2024 ruling, Judge John Napper wrote that an updated version of the Secretary of State's Election Procedures Manual allows for the use of old ballot envelopes for signature verification. And he found the Arizona Legislature chose to accept that allowance as it updated the state’s election laws.
“The Legislature had every opportunity to eliminate ‘prior early ballot affidavits’ as a comparison tool but chose not to do so. Nothing in these amendments suggests the Legislature found the EPM's working definition of registration record was improper,” Napper wrote.
On Wednesday, an Arizona Court of Appeals panel upheld the lower court ruling.
The judges found the Arizona Republican Party and other plaintiffs did not have standing to sue in the first place, according to an opinion authored by Judge Jeffrey Sklar.
Sklar wrote that the plaintiffs disagree with the way the Secretary of State Adrian Fontes interpreted the state law governing signature verification, not that Fontes failed to fulfill duties the secretary of state is required to perform.
“This amounts to issue advocacy, which as we have explained, cannot confer standing,” Sklar wrote.
An attorney for the plaintiffs said they have not yet decided whether to appeal the ruling to the Arizona Supreme Court.
-
Find everything you need to know about elections in Arizona and Maricopa County from KJZZ's politics team. -
Two third-party candidates who are under an investigation by the Arizona Citizens Clean Elections Commission that could force them to pay back millions in public funding have filed a lawsuit challenging the commission’s power to claw back the money. -
More than 900 thousand voters registered in Maricopa County have no party affiliation, a larger group than either Democrats or Republicans. -
Republican Congressman Juan Ciscomani and Democrat Joanna Mendoza sparred over the direction of the country under the second Trump administration as they made their pitch to voters in Arizona’s Congressional District 6, one of just a few competitive districts that could determine which party controls Congress next year. -
Democrat hopefuls Jonathon Hill and Clara Pratte accused Republican incumbent Kevin Thompson for out-of-control data center development and rising utility bills.
