Starting Friday, Arizona will require age verification to access adult websites. Users will have to prove they’re at least 18 years old. One option under the new law is to upload government-issued ID.
But this law is raising enforcement questions by opponents, including Michael Stabile with the Free Speech Coalition, which represents the adult entertainment industry. He says when forced to verify their age, viewers just move on to other sites.
“What we find is that consumers do not comply with this law. When our members have attempted to comply with this law in other states, 95% of the people have left. They've gone someplace else, because the internet is global," Stabile said.
And adult websites outside the U.S. will likely not follow domestic screening laws.
The law is also raising concerns among some opponents who worry this could have a chilling effect on free speech.
The law is aimed at restricting access to "sexual material that is harmful to minors," like pornography.
“That's still in the title of the bill, but pornography is not the subject of the bill,” says Jeanne Woodbury, an associate lobbyist with Creosote Partners who lobbies for the ACLU. She says the issue is how “sexual material” is defined.
“And the definition of sexual material harmful to minors is very subjective. It's open to interpretation. And so one parent's understanding of what that means could encompass standard sexual education, and it could encompass descriptions and information about even domestic violence," Woodbury said.
Rep. Nick Kupper, the Surprise Republican who crafted the legislation that takes effect Friday, says the law applies only to sites where a third of its content is considered sexual material harmful to minors.
“So if you're hosting content that some parents might think is sexual material that's harmful to minors, those parents, if their kids go to that website, could now potentially sue you.”
For tens of thousands of dollars — which, critics say, could have a chilling effect on free speech.
Supporters also say this new law offers another layer of protection beyond just asking if the user is 18.
-
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem held a press conference in metro Phoenix to advocate for the SAVE Act, legislation that would require Americans to provide proof of citizenship when registering to vote — something that’s already state law in Arizona. -
Arizona and the six other states that use the Colorado River do not have a new plan to share the shrinking water supply. -
The Maricopa County Board of Supervisors will re-issue subpoenas requiring Recorder Justin Heap’s staff to testify about conflicting voter disenfranchisement claims after a judge allows a court order blocking the subpoenas to expire next week. -
Arizonans are speaking out after the Trump administration announced it would rescind the key scientific finding that allows the Environmental Protection Agency to put limits on carbon pollution. -
Community members and activists gathered outside the Arizona Capitol to call for the continuation of independent oversight of the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office connected to a nearly 20-year-old racial profiling case against the department.
