LAUREN GILGER: Arizona State University has enlisted a former state Supreme Court justice to conduct an independent review of what led to the collapse of hockey player Matthew Mayich. The 21-year-old sophomore remains on life support after being taken to the hospital after a military-style outdoor workout on Aug. 20. He is not expected to recover.
Last week, ASU placed hockey coach Greg Powers on administrative leave. And now, the university says it’s hiring former Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Scott Bales to review the facts in the case.
This, after seven anonymous players sent a letter to ASU President Michael Crow. In it, they dispute the university’s account of events the day Mayich collapsed and claim the workout was described initially as a team-building exercise, but was actually a quote “military-style conditioning session” in which players were not given adequate water breaks and some vomited.
So, what is the purpose of these so-called military-style workouts in collegiate or professional sports? Why are they prominent today?
For more on that, I got a hold of Dr. Adam Annaccone, clinical associate professor of kinesiology at the University of Texas at Arlington and chief health and performance advisor for the Athletic Department there. He also used to be an assistant athletic trainer with the Suns about a decade ago.
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: So, I think it’s important upfront to recognize that military-style workout is not actually a recognized type of workout. It is more of a team-building training type component. The physical activity attributes to it are just everyday activities, from running to burpees to crawling, right? So, any type of physical activity can be incorporated into these team-building activities.
So, I don’t want people to think that there’s like a specific training method called military workout that strength and conditioning and athletic training and personal trainers and what have you, like abide by and learn in school to implement.
LAUREN GILGER: Right, so this refers to the military-style thing, like kind of refers to the purpose of the workout as opposed to exactly what you’re doing?
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Yeah, absolutely. It’s really separating the behavioral objective from the physiological stress. And the behavioral objective is trying to get athletes uncomfortable, challenged, communicating and solving problems together that lead to team building or better team building. And that’s the military component.
So, Navy SEALs, Green Berets, like they are challenged physically in hopes that there’s adversity that then brings the unit together. And through that component, you know, hopefully you can read each other’s minds. You know what their next step is going to be, right? You’ve experienced the worst, you’ve come together as a group, and moved beyond that together. It’s not one individual that’s responsible for it, it’s the entire team coming together.
LAUREN GILGER: So, the goal is just sort of team build, challenge, but in a not just a physical way, it sounds like, in a mental and kind of team way as well.
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Yeah, I mean, the goal is often team unity, trust, communication, working together under stress.
LAUREN GILGER: Under stress, right. So, I mean, I imagine with a military-style workout, you know, someone yelling, maybe pushing folks to their limits or to what might be harder for them than they are used to. Would that be a part of it?
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. It’s creating an environment that’s stressful using various methods. So, yeah, using yelling, you know, loud environment, just creating an environment that’s chaotic. And on top of that, kind of how you build that stress is utilizing different types of exercises and physical activity to get the body in a almost a fatigued state.
LAUREN GILGER: OK. So, that sounds difficult and maybe dangerous. How do you as a trainer — and I know you have done this with teams and you work in this kind of role with the university there now — but how do you make sure that this is done safely?
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Yeah, I mean, it goes back to planning. And the analogy that I use all the time is you would never go and build a house without first developing the blueprint, getting all the contractors together, all the experts together, and walk through that blueprint and make sure everyone’s on the same page and everyone knows their job and their role and who’s doing what. And should something go sideways, who has the authority to say, "Hey, let’s stop, let's look at this, let's reevaluate it"?
And then there’s the physiological component of it, and that’s what I was talking about before in separating the two, is, OK, since this involves physical stress and physical activity, let’s make sure we’re following sound scientific physiological principles.
And with that, we have to understand the duration, we have to understand the volume, the intensity. We have to take the environment into consideration, the weather that day. We have to take readiness into consideration. So, what’s been the training level of individuals coming in prior to this? What environment have they been training in? We can’t neglect the sound physiological components that are necessary when we’re programming out a physical activity.
LAUREN GILGER: You were an assistant athletic trainer with the Suns. It sounds like you’ve done this kind of Navy SEAL-type workout with professional athletes. What did it look like for you?
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Yeah, I mean, for us, thankfully, we had training camp up in Flagstaff. But still with that, you know, our director of performance at the time and the other medical experts that I was with, we worked very well together as a team. And we had conversations going into that training camp as to what this was going to look like, who are we bringing in, what do they want to do, what type of physical activity were we trying to accomplish, what were the objectives and goals that we wanted to do?
And we settled on the fact that this was really the first day of training camp. And so it was more kind of paring down a lot of what they would do with the Navy SEAL or Green Beret or what have you, and just exposing them to some of the adversity that military-style individuals or military units implement to create that adversity.
And then we had conversations around individual players and their limitations and what we wanted them to achieve and not achieve, and everyone was on the same page.
LAUREN GILGER: Let me ask you lastly, I mean, I asked you about sort of the way that these kind of workouts can be carried out in a safe way. But let me ask you then also, I mean, have you seen these kinds of workouts go wrong?
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: I personally have not seen these type of workouts go wrong, but if we can take a higher-level approach, I think these type of workouts in any type of environment can go awry when there isn’t clear authority. And I speak to this a lot even in the classroom. You can have a really good policy, but a really good policy doesn’t translate into it being operated the way it should in practice.
And in that regards, like the governance piece, everyone needs to understand that they have the authority to speak up when they see something going sideways, or even if something doesn’t seem right, everyone should feel comfortable enough to be able to speak up and almost call a timeout and say, "Wait a minute, I’m going to call a timeout here. This doesn’t seem right. Can we huddle really quickly and talk about it"?
And I think from emergency situations I’ve seen and been a part of simulations I’ve been a part of, that’s really the challenging aspect is when that authority piece isn’t clearly communicated ahead of time. And when people feel like they don’t have the permission to speak up and say something or it isn’t clearly defined that they can speak up, then I think that’s where, you know, people start second-guessing. You second-guess whether or not you should actually say something, and we shouldn’t really be troubleshooting this in the moment.
Everyone should know that they have the authority to hit that red stop button when they see something, because ultimately it’s about the health and safety of the individuals that are going through the activity.
LAUREN GILGER: OK. Dr. Adam Annaccone joining us, clinical associate professor of kinesiology at the University of Texas at Arlington, chief health and performance adviser for the athletic department there as well. Thank you so much for coming on, Doctor. Appreciate you taking the time to talk this through.
DR. ADAM ANNACCONE: Of course. Thank you for having me.
-
Long-distance runner Louis Tewanima lays claim to being the first Arizonan to ever make the podium at the Olympic Games. In 1912, the very same year Arizona became a state, Tewanima won a silver medal in Stockholm, Sweden.
-
The Major League Baseball season is over, and the sport faces an uncertain 2027. It can often be a game of heartbreak. But for Mark Athitakis, fall baseball in the Valley inspires optimism.
-
City officials are unveiling a new mural in a North Phoenix park Saturday – it’s not just a piece of art, but a heat-mitigation experiment.
-
Now, along with returning to the conference he helped launch, Dave Hakstol is tasked with restoring a program that has been rife with controversy following an outdoor workout that left defenseman Matthew Mayich hospitalized after he collapsed from heat stroke at Sun Angel Stadium on Aug. 20.
-
The popular West Fork Trail No. 108 between Flagstaff and Sedona will be closed for the foreseeable future due to hazardous conditions from recent flooding.